everything wrong with star wars prequels
They could have just squeezed all 3 prequels into the first and given us 2 dark action packed prequels with Vader. They’re still deeply flawed movies, but there’s also a lot to appreciate in these products of unrestrained creativity. He brought all-new flairs to Obi-Wan’s character while honoring his legacy. They’re just bad movies. 37. It’s not a perfect movie by any means, but it does have its moments — and more importantly, it’s a satisfying bridge between the events of the prequel trilogy and the events of the original trilogy. Whatever they thought of themselves, they couldn't have been perfect in their understanding of the Force or they wouldn't have been destroyed by the Emperor. And I love the original three Star Wars movies, I really do. The prequels are a cold, joyless experience, spawned by the uninhibited mania of George Lucas and his mob of adoring yes-men. Star Wars Episodes I-III are a veritable treasure trove of poor decision-making. Name a single good film ever made about a trade dispute. Before they made the prequels, Anakin Skywalker was a good pilot lured to the dark side of the force. All rights reserved. But that alone isn’t enough to inspire hatred. After all the waiting the audience only ever gets to see him at the end of the last prequel...pathetic! George Lucas will defend this character until the day he dies. The 'Star Wars' prequel trilogy isn't as bad as you may remember, and worth revisiting before 'The Last Jedi.' "There's always a bigger fish." Critics have since highlighted the many things wrong with the film and its sequels Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith: George Lucas’s … 0:07 Sadly, she wasn’t around to do the same for the prequels. The original trilogy had political commentary — it was George Lucas’ allegorical critique of the Vietnam War — but the political aspects were hidden in the spectacle. By Ben Aldis Published May 13, 2020 A one-stop shop for all things video games. How did Leia remember so much about her mother if she died during childbirth? Here are the nine dumbest decisions in the Star Wars prequels. Throughout the prequels, there is a feeling of immense lifelessness. He never redeemed himself with any courage or moment of intuition; he just screwed up throughout the entire movie. People talk about how the prequels dragged down the original trilogy, but what they don’t talk about is how the prequels would never have been any kind of box office hit without the original trilogy to give them a readymade support base. Ben Sherlock is a writer, comedian, and independent filmmaker, and he's good at at least two of those things. The fun of this galaxy is that it’s full of spaceships blowing each other up, so it was disappointing to have to sit through long, drawn-out political debates in the prequel trilogy. Even if you choose to ignore the prequels, it is clear that the Jedi have fallen. It’s easier to appreciate how much George Lucas strived to expand the worldbuilding in the prequels after five years of Disney relying entirely on nostalgia from the original trilogy’s iconography. At the end of the third prequel, we watched a long and drawn out lightsaber battle between four protagonists (Yoda versus Palpatine and Obi-wan versus Anakin) who we knew were going to survive anyway. It was a huge risk and it’s unclear how it’ll pay off. Why didn’t Artoo remember anyone? And they’re bad movies that made great movies kind of worse. While every movie was a hit, fans have liked some more than the others. We could probably have forgiven the incredibly bad dialogue, pointless plots, and lack of character if the universe hadn’t been populated with added irritation. All contents © 2021 The Slate Group LLC. He embodied the character’s younger self without simply doing an Alec Guinness impression. After polarizing the Star Wars fan base with The Last Jedi, Disney went hell for leather with The Rise of Skywalker by bringing back Ian McDiarmid as Emperor Palpatine, who supposedly died in Return of the Jedi. RELATED: Star Wars: The Best Scene In Every Movie, Ranked. MassGeekdom. Apparently, Jar Jar is his favorite Star Wars character. I read alot about fans of the original star wars hating them, maybe it was cos i grew up & saw the first 3 as a child but i loved them, in fairness though i've never watched the older ones consistently straight-through. Everything wrong with the prequels was a result of George’s hubris, failing to recognize the original trilogy succeeded because of the team he had working with him. He bumbled around in the background of conversations, he stepped in shit, got farted on, and generally behaved like the cheapest comic relief character there was. He's currently in pre-production on his first feature film, Hunting Trip, and has been for a while because filmmaking is expensive. But please, you MUST realise that the star wars prequels are an exception to this. Anyways was it just that the prequels made Star Wars real commercial (hence why me, a non-fan of the originals enjoyed it so much) or were the fans just nit-picking at … George Lucas' Star Wars prequels are secretly brilliant, even if they have a lot of flaws. The first two prequels were pointless, and they felt like they were pointless. 100 positives of 2020 30 cute dog photos Celebrity babies We're here to … -- only, you … Basically Qui-Gon's version of "Never the tell me the odds!" Learn from experts and access insider knowledge. I would have said, Lucas couldn’t kill Star Wars with those still-born prequels! On Williams’ end, he composed tracks such as “Duel of the Fates” and “Battle of the Heroes” that were just as breathtaking and instantly memorable as original tracks like “The Imperial March” and “The Force Theme.”. Slate is published by The Slate Group, a Graham Holdings Company. RELATED: Star Wars: 5 Things The Phantom Menace Did Better Than The Force Awakens (And 5 The Force Awakens Did Better). So when George Lucas announced, many years later, that he would be releasing the prequels to Star Wars, I was soooo excited. But compared to the new films, a wave of nostalgia is growing. . On Burtt’s end, he never failed to astound when he’d come up with a sound for something that doesn’t exist that ends up working perfectly. Darth Vader comes in at No. With the imminent release of Star Wars: Episode II, I have spent a lot of time reflecting on Star Wars: Episode I, The Phantom Menace.Every time I get into a heated discussion with Paul, Laura and Jacques about this (which is every time I speak with any of them) we always start bringing up specific segments of the movie that we hated. The original trilogy didn’t need a purely comic relief character—it was able to intuitively find comedic moments in the course of the movie. It’s not Han Solo or Darth Vader or Leia Organa or Obi-Wan Kenobi; it’s Jar Jar Binks. The reason the Star Wars prequels fail so spectacularly, both as Star Wars films and science fiction cinema, is a total lack of humanity. Jar Jar, along with the two incredibly annoying Anakins, were just irritating throughout the entire trilogy. Because they’re not as good as the first trilogy, and the expectations were high. Another weekend, another bad take on the internet making people mad. This is why Carrie Fisher had to punch up the original trilogy’s dialogue on-set. While Lucas is a veritable genius in the art of storytelling, drawing mainly on Japanese cinema and comparative mythology, he stumbles in some areas of the execution. Star Wars. In addition to writing news and features for Game Rant and lists for Screen Rant and CBR, Ben directs independent films and does standup comedy. Ewan McGregor could’ve easily gone down in film history as an Alden Ehrenreich when he took on the role of young Obi-Wan Kenobi in the Star Wars prequel trilogy. A big part of the appeal of the original trilogy was the simple battle between good and evil. 3 on the bad guys list, and Han Solo at No. I prefer the Star Wars prequels. As much as fans are divided over The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones, most Star Wars fans can agree that Revenge of the Sith is a pretty good movie that successfully wrapped up the trilogy. When he first conceived Star Wars, George Lucas saw it as a six-part story (or a nine-part story, or a twelve-part story, depending on what rumor you believe) and he chose to tell the fourth part first intentionally to draw in fans with the most exciting part. 1. George Lucas will defend this character until the day he dies. And the prequels gave him a chance to play the Chancellor Palpatine side with a deceptive campiness, hiding the Sith Lord within. No characters from the prequels trouble the list at all, and how could they? There, I said it. But McGregor crushed it. You don’t need to tell George Lucas that he’s not the most gifted writer of romantic dialogue, because he’s the first to admit it himself. I grew up ankle deep in action figures, and logged so many gaming hours on Atari’s The Empire Strikes Back that even my dreams were pixilated. And he never had a moment of redemption. 14 on the list of good guys supported by Obi Wan Kenobi (the Alec Guiness, original trilogy version) at No. There was a lot of standing around talking about stuff and having votes in senates and generally not doing interesting things with lightsabers. Had you told me in 2015 that as a film franchise Star Wars would be dead in five years, that it would survive only as a television show, I would have called you crazy. My son is ready to watch Star Wars for the first time: What are best practices? If I’m going to watch people talk about trade disputes, then I want to watch interesting characters delivering snappy dialogue. 3:35. Lucas knew the story in broad strokes, but adapted each part as he came to actually bring it to the screen, which is why Luke and Leia kiss in Empire, then get revealed as twins in Jedi. NEXT: Star Wars: 5 Things The Prequel Trilogy Did Better Than The Sequel Trilogy (& 5 Things The Sequels Are Doing Better). “Episode VIII: The Last Jedi” After Ewoks, a disappointing prequel trilogy, and an entertaining rehash … There are many movies in the Star Wars series - the original trilogy, the prequel trilogy, the sequel trilogy, and the standalone films like Rogue One and Solo: A Star Wars Story. But now we know he’s a whiny and annoying kid and a hopelessly acted romantic fool and inexplicably the guy who designed C3PO and R2D2’s best friend. As the Disney Star Wars trilogy draws to a close with The Rise of Skywalker, which opens Dec. 20, I find myself genuinely longing for the days of the prequels. . Emma Watson Retires From Acting & Fans On Twitter Are Not Okay, Star Wars: 5 Things The Prequel Trilogy Did Wrong (& 5 It Did Right), Star Wars: 5 Things The Phantom Menace Did Better Than The Force Awakens (And 5 The Force Awakens Did Better), he went back into the original trilogy to ruin that, too, Star Wars: 5 Things Ewan McGregor Brought (& 5 Things Alec Guinness Brought) To Obi-Wan Kenobi, just as breathtaking and instantly memorable as original tracks, Star Wars: The Best Scene In Every Movie, Ranked, it’s full of spaceships blowing each other up, McDiarmid will continue to nail the character, Star Wars: 10 Greatest Emperor Palpatine Moments To Get You Excited For His Return, the heartbreaking emotional payoff of Obi-Wan and Anakin’s climactic lightsaber battle, Star Wars: 5 Things The Prequel Trilogy Did Better Than The Sequel Trilogy (& 5 Things The Sequels Are Doing Better), Harry Potter: The Most Powerful Families, Ranked, 10 Great Movies To Watch On Netflix When You're Happy, Alien: 5 Mind-Blowing Moments (& 5 Fans Want To Forget), Harry Potter: 5 Ways Harry's Ending Is Fitting (& 5 Why It Makes No Sense), Agatha All Along & 9 Other Iconic Villain Theme Songs, Star Trek: The Motion Picture - 10 Things That Make No Sense, Harry Potter: The Death Eaters, Ranked By Power, MCU: 5 Things We Know About Captain Marvel 2 (& 5 Fan Theories), 5 Redeemable Sci-Fi Movie Villains (& 5 That Are Too Evil), Godzilla vs. Kong: The MonsterVerse Human Characters, Ranked By Likability, The 10 Best Uses Of Elvis Presley Songs In Movies, 'I Care A Lot': Why Fans On Twitter Are So Divided Over The Movie, Harry Potter: The Hogwarts Professors, Ranked By Power, Total Recall & 9 Other Mind-Bending Sci-Fi Actioners, Inside Llewyn Davis & 9 Other Amazing Movies About Music, Top 10 Movies From The 2010s On Netflix, Ranked By Rotten Tomatoes, Star Trek: Generations - 10 Things That Make No Sense, 10 Movies To Watch If You Like Netflix's I Care A Lot. 0:08 [PDF Download] Star Wars Chronicles: The Prequels [PDF] Online. He’s just wrong all over. Poor Green-Screen Execution. Audiences come to Star Wars movies for the escapism. Darth Vader is Star Wars, without him a Star Wars film is nothing. At the end of Return of the Jedi, we watched as the good guys fell into a trap. Hailed by many as “the best Star Wars project since the Original Trilogy,” the show has given Star Wars fans several story arcs that have gone on to become favorites. The reason everyone should hate them is because they take away from the original trilogy. Alec Guinness made Kenobi an icon of the silver screen as he mentored Luke Skywalker through the original trilogy, and as one of the greatest actors who ever lived, Guinness was tough to follow up. But the prequels were about trade disputes. Unfortunately, the prequels mess up some of the continuity when you line them up with the original trilogy. The original trilogy gave us a great story arc with an incredibly exciting conclusion. So, here are 5 Things The Star Wars Prequel Trilogy Did Wrong (% 5 It Did Right). If Phantom Menace had been the first Star Wars movie made, then it would just be a forgotten-about series of movies by now with only a limited fanbase. The last movie in the original trilogy and the sequel trilogy were two movies that were successful financially, but elicited mixed reactions. The third prequel started to move in the right direction, but for many it was too little, too late. Until a few years ago, the Star Wars prequel trilogy was universally panned by both diehard fans and casual moviegoers. Darth Vader and Emperor were bad, and Luke and Co. weren’t, and the bad guys wanted to … He anchored the prequel trilogy more than Anakin himself did. And also because they’re just really bad movies in their own right. Here everything is soft and smooth. The lacklustre CGI is demonstrably used as a band-aid to compensate for massive failings throughout every other aspect of the films – AND GUESS WHAT! It doesn’t use the fact that it can end with the beginning of A New Hope as a crutch; it tells its own story in its own time, with the heartbreaking emotional payoff of Obi-Wan and Anakin’s climactic lightsaber battle feeling earned. We all have mundane lives and Star Wars movies offer us a chance to leave those lives behind and escape to a galaxy far, far away for a couple of hours. 2. You can say you miss the miniatures. Ewan McGregor, Liam Neeson, and Jake Lloyd in. You can say that Puppet Yoda will be the one true Yoda in your heart. RELATED: Star Wars: 10 Greatest Emperor Palpatine Moments To Get You Excited For His Return. The good guys were losing and it was hard to see any way out. Actor Ahmed Best faced a lot of the backlash for this character, and that’s not really fair, because the character was fundamentally flawed from his creation — it’s not Best’s fault; it’s what he was given to work with. The prequel trilogy introduced us to Coruscant, the monarchy of Naboo, the Wookiees’ home planet Kashyyyk, the Trade Federation, the Jedi Council — even when the prequels took us back to Tatooine, we were shown new corners of Tatooine. Too much BAD CGI 3. They can very clearly and irrefutably be demonstrated to be incompetently scripted, acted, plotted, and paced. The prequels are boring and annoying and soulless, but then so are lots of other movies. Why did the Death Star take thirty years to construct? Lucas allowed Hayden Christensen and Natalie Portman to rewrite a lot of their dialogue, but “I don’t like sand” still made the cut. This question originally appeared on Quora, the best answer to any question. You can say that Empire Strikes back is the best Star Wars movie of all time. Here are the highs and lows. A theme of this list is that what many of the CGI characters in the Star Wars prequels lack in realistic-looking visual rendering, they make up for with sound. There are a few ways, from the Dungeons & Dragons moral alignment chart to the MBTI personality types to the … Yeah. The Star Wars prequel movies introduced many fan-favorites, too, from Mace Windu to Count Dooku and Padme Amidala.. RELATED: 10 Incredible Generous Grievous Cosplays (That Every Star Wars Fan Needs to See) How can you decide which character you identify most with? AFI listed the greatest heroes and villains of all time in 2003. To be fair to George Lucas, CGI was in its infancy when he made the Star Wars prequel trilogy, and he was one of the pioneers at the forefront of its technological advancement. 2r6mvd. The closest thing they have to an interesting bad guy is Darth Maul, and he’s only in the trilogy for about 15 minutes. Darth Vader and Emperor were bad, and Luke and Co. weren’t, and the bad guys wanted to wipe the good guys out, so war ensued, and good films were the result. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. Lucas was so excited by the new technology that he didn’t feel like ruining the prequel trilogy’s aesthetic with an abundance of primitive CGI effects was enough and he went back into the original trilogy to ruin that, too, with the so-called “Special Editions.” The prequels’ overuse of CGI is distracting, especially now that CGI technologies have gotten even better. The only interesting good guy is Obi Wan, and that’s mainly because McGregor is doing an Alec Guinness impression. Credit: hitfix. George Lucas has said recently that his biggest problem with The Force Awakens was its unwillingness to take risks. RELATED: Star Wars: 5 Things Ewan McGregor Brought (& 5 Things Alec Guinness Brought) To Obi-Wan Kenobi. And Darth Vader wasn’t the baddest of the bad who had his moment of redemption—he was a hopeless loser shouting a hilariously awful “Noooooo” to the heavens. I don’t want to spend my time listening to terrible writing while wondering, “Why the hell are these evil capitalists speaking with Asian accents? Did the Rebel Alliance really blow up the Death Star, or was it all planned by Vader and the Emperor to drum up support for their war against the terrorists. Fans’ hatred is justified. Now the Sequels were the worst thing to ever happen to Star Wars, with Rose Tico and Amilyn Holdo (nicknamed Admiral Gender Studies by many … They also want to see the continuation of the saga’s ongoing story and revisit their favorite characters, but primarily, the appeal is that pure escapism. The actor has always done a fantastic job of playing the character’s Darth Sidious persona as a snarling, mustache-twirling menace. The 3 episode's third and final act is arguably the crucial moment … How TUPAC Almost Became Mace Windu in Star Wars Prequels - Star Wars Rumor CONFIRMED (BessY) Jaleesadog. You must be out of your mind! 10 Reasons You’re Wrong About The Star Wars Prequels. He wasn’t funny at all, and the need to insert him into every scene made him even more annoying. But as the millennials who grew up with the prequels have become outspoken adults and Disney’s attempt at a sequel trilogy has shown us how quickly Star Wars can go off the rails without George Lucas — or just a single guiding creative vision — the prequels have come to be reconsidered. You can follow Quora on Twitter, Facebook, and Google Plus. I Still Love Star Wars Everything Wrong With the Star Wars Prequels. Just look at Obi-Wan’s seismic charge in Attack of the Clones, which is a beautiful sound effect — and delaying it because of the space setting was a nice touch. A big part of the appeal of the original trilogy was the simple battle between good and evil. At the time, the ability to fill the frame with all kinds of computer-generated dreck was a fresh novelty. John Williams and Ben Burtt continued to nail the musical score and the sound design for Star Wars, respectively, when George Lucas brought them back for the prequels. Aside from being irritating beyond all belief, Jar Jar is a cartoonish amalgamation of several offensive cultural stereotypes. Ugalde- ... That is what i think was wrong with the prequel trilogy. Ask a question, get a great answer. Disney Chose The Wrong Timeline For The Star Wars Sequels Disney’s Star Wars trilogy skimped on everything that fans wanted to see, most notably the major events that transpired after Return of the Jedi. There was no tension, no excitement, just a sense of relief that it was all finally ending. The original trilogy had one of the most iconic villains in movie history and put him against some truly charismatic heros. It was dull—even worse, it was badly written dull. TeeeVeee? Previously, he wrote for Taste of Cinema and BabbleTop. What’s that all about?”. Apparently, Jar Jar is his favorite Star Wars character.… For movies that were supposed to be about Darth Vader's Start of Darkness, we really didn't get a chance to FEEL his fall from grace. No wonder people hate them. Jar Jar was a huge mistake on every level. The realism of the original trilogy has been digitally washed away in … But one thing is for sure: McDiarmid will continue to nail the character. Setting Up The Originals Perfectly. 8 years ago. Yesterday it was this article from CNET that made the bold claim that “The New Star Wars trilogy is worse than the prequels.” Two hours later, I was hooked. Perhaps none have had the emotional impact as the Wrong Jedi arc, wherein Ahsoka Tano is wrongly accused of committing a terrorist act against the Republic. The Star Wars prequel trilogy has been universally panned. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Introduction. We’ll finally be seeing more of McGregor’s Obi-Wan in an upcoming Disney+ series. Not like here. I am assuming you mean Star Wars the third one was pretty good , I was disappointed in Solo only because the book is so good . With all of his Star Wars movies, he continued to expand the universe. Han and Leia were captured on Endor, the fleet was about to be blown up by the Death Star, and Luke was considering a move to the dark side. On Star Wars, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Everything that's wrong with the prequels list".